Who would you bet on??????

Just an interesting subject nuthing bad meant by it just curiosity, if yall were at ringside and had to place bets who would it be on ch chinaman or gr ch buck at 46lbs??????? no wrong answers just honest opinions :rolleyes:

http://www.apbt.online-pedigrees.com/modules.php?name=Public&file=printPedigree&dog_id=26


http://www.apbt.online-pedigrees.com/modules.php?name=Public&file=printPedigree&dog_id=428

 

hands down chinaman i dont think buck could handle his mouth

 

buck for me, the quality he beat was far in excess of nearly any dogout there,from all accounts a strong dog with loads of wrestling ability, an ace.although its a tough call if you saw neither in action

 

very good point

 

Damn that would be one awesome match up. If I had to pick one and bet the farm, I going with Chinaman.

I honestly think its a toss up, both aces, therefore I'll bet on the Pedigree. Chinaman for the win.

 

Tough one to call , if chinaman could get to where he wanted with buck tucked up in the corner then i'd say chinaman, on the other hand if buck could break dance all over chinaman and wear him down ,then i'd go with buck !!!! Both good dogs in their own rights

 

I'd put my money on GR Ch Buck !!!

A friend of mine used to own Buck for a while, and he said Buck had it all. Not that chinaman didnt, but earned Grand champion against some of the best. He's gotta be one hell of a dog!

 

I would bet on Buck. It'd tough to win 3, let alone 5! Gotta go with the 5x winner!

 

I'd take Buck too.

 

buck won 7

 

1 aldos ch zeke in 35
2 pats conan in 25
3 titos tonka in 27
4 captain americas jumbo jim in 1.51
5 rodneys J.R. 2xw in 53
6 johnsons ch rocky in 1.06
7 rebels gr ch sandman in 3.17


not too shabby a record, up with the best i would say.

 

nice thread....but just to hijack it......who would you put in with double g/ch tornado??:cool:

 

the one that was her size i would say most would say had an even shot would be Molly B

 

i think i might have to say buck too....and to add to this what if banjo/ andy capp had gone off

 

What was her size SB??

 

andy capp was a little bigger

 

she was 42 lbs al

 

buck for me. he went the distance, 3hrs, 2 hrs, 1hr and some short destroying 30 min hits. chinaman i dont think ever went close to that time so based on that alone, buck for me as the safe bet

 

Agreed - the fact that he went so deep especially in #7 puts him over for me. As we know, each time the dog is out takes a little out of him, so to last over 3 hrs w/ another Gr Ch in #7 is really impressive.

 

truthfully I like them chinaman dogs

BUT!!!

if the two were to meet I think that buck would comeout on top
records show that he was a true ace he could finish in shot order
OR!!
he could go for the long haul when put to the test

not taking anything away from chinaman as I belive he was a good dog in his own right
I never knew if he proved to be game but he did prove to be a devestating killing dog

but can he go 3hrs?I dont know
If he could adapt to a style that would call for a lot of dancing and would be the deciding factor

even if chinaman does show to be deepgame can he keep him self out of trouble long enough to get an oppertunity to finish