1. Welcome to Game Dog Forum


    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Game Dog Forum is volunteer run and member supported. Member contributions pay for hosting and software upgrades. If you derive value from the community on Game Dog, we ask that you consider supporting the forum by purchasing a premium membership. You'll get access to our chat room and private forum. Click here to pay for a yearly premium membership, only $10 or $25 for three years! http://www.game-dog.com/index.php?donate/ Even if you can't contribute today, we're glad you're here. We hope you enjoy this Game Dog forum and community.

Melbourne's pit bull ban may be lifted

Discussion in 'Laws & Legislation' started by Vicki, Mar 24, 2016.

  1. Vicki

    Vicki Administrator Staff Member

    Melbourne's pit bull ban may be lifted

    March 24, 2016 Liam Mannix

    Pit bulls could be back on the streets of Melbourne soon after a parliamentary report found it was impossible to tell if they were any more dangerous than other dogs.

    The ban on the breed, in place since 2011, could be lifted if the recommendations are adopted by the state government.

    The dogs were banned after the death of little Ayen Chol, mauled by a 40-kilogram pit bull in 2011.

    But the committee says that ban has failed, with local councils unable to accurately identify pit bulls. Local councils quoted in the report say it is "impossible" to identify dangerous dogs just by looking at them.

    Studies on pit bull aggressiveness and danger were inconclusive, the report found, and it was impossible from the data to say they were more dangerous than other types of dogs.

    Many people who made submissions to the inquiry argued there was a "moral panic" going on against pit bulls, and that media reporting of pit bull attacks had been inaccurate and sensationalist.

    The committee's finding echoes the vast majority of submissions, with groups including the RSPCA, Animals Australia and the Australian Veterinary Association all calling for an end to the ban.

    Ayen was killed when an American pit bull ran from a neighbour's house into the little girl's St Albans home and attacked her, her aunt and her sister.

    Ayen's mother, Jacklin Ancaito, has strongly advocated for firm penalties for the owners of dogs who attack people.

    Among the other recommendations of the committee:

    the muzzling of non-racing greyhounds no longer be required;

    building a database of all dog registrations and attacks;

    and greater penalties for owners of restricted-breed dogs who do not register them correctly or keep them securely.

    836 Victorians were hospitalised after dog attacks in 2013-14 according to the committee's report.

    The difficulty councils have in classifying dangerous dogs was highlighted by the case of Mylo the American Staffordshire terrier cross.

    Mylo was seized from his family's Sunshine West home in 2012 after council officers branded him a pit bull.

    It took a DNA test paid for by Mylo's family to win the dog a reprieve, after he had sat on death row at the council pound for 22 months.

    Staffordshire Bull Terrier Club of Victoria president Patrick Walsh welcomed the committee's findings.

    "It was a knee jerk reaction. Any dog can be dangerous in the wrong hands," he said.

    "No dog is dangerous in the right hands. I've met pit bulls before and never had a problem with them, but the owners were responsible. It's like kids – if the parents don't bring them up right, they cause a problem."

    Staffordshire terriers are the pure-bred forefathers of pit bulls, Mr Walsh said, before they were cross-bred with other species to create the modern pit bull.

    His family own three and he describes them as the gentlest dogs he's seen.

    Minister for Agriculture Jaala Pulford moved on Wednesday to extend the current moratorium on the compulsory euthanasia of pit bulls while she considers the report.

    "We must keep the community safe and to do that our laws need to be effective – that's why we asked the Parliament to review these laws so that we can get them right."

    Opposition agriculture minister Peter Walsh said: "Daniel Andrews must put the community's safety first if he is going to change Victoria's dangerous dogs laws.

    "The Premier must do everything he can to ensure we never have a repeat of the tragedy we saw in 2011 when a young child was killed by a pit bull."

    Melbourne's pit bull ban may be lifted
  2. Roveros

    Roveros Pup

    Staffordshire terriers are the pure-bred forefathers of pit bulls, Mr Walsh said, before they were cross-bred with other species to create the modern pit bull.

    There is always a good laugh from the show dog crowd.
  3. Robertosilva

    Robertosilva CH Dog

    There wasn't a set breed called The Staffordshire Bull Terrier until 1935. I think he must mean the old Bull and Terriers.

    3 types of Bull and Terriers from Staffordshire considered for the breed standard below.

    One from Cradley Heath, one from Darleston and one from Walsall all within a few miles of each other.

    They went with the first one as that is what Joe Mallen and Joe Dunn of the Staffordshire Bull Terrier club preferred.


Share This Page