1. Welcome to Game Dog Forum

    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

    Dismiss Notice

Did successful dogmen ever breed curs?

Discussion in 'Dog Discussion' started by sciri21, Jan 22, 2019.

  1. old goat

    old goat CH Dog

    Well I missed it I guess ask again .
     
  2. Boze

    Boze Top Dog

    The thing about sapello that made home give her a chance was prety much like you said she was bred second to none. But also sapelo was some boys house dog who had to move and the wife didn’t want no dog ruining her new home. And without any schooling what so ever was just thrown in there the first time for 45 and showed prety good. Now I ain’t making excuses bit that is the story. Also if you ask boleros owner he will tell you his opinion of Taz which is he was a cur to at least he thought so. If you notice and follow that blood you will see the good dogs do to what was bred by him a what he kept for himself. Nothing of taz. Nothing of Bo even though he was the baddest 43 maybe that baddest dog ever. Also never bred to or kept dogs of huckleberry even though he was a great dog he’ll even nothing of arangadanga and that was because he had New Granny who would have I quote “ would have stolen arangadanga’s lunch” lol and new granny was never campaigned but kept for brood for a reason
     
    Blackpolarbear likes this.
  3. Boze

    Boze Top Dog

    The reason a cut can produce game dogs is simple genetics. Now that’s if you believe gameness is a gene which I do. If you study behavioral genetic you will see a word called heritability which is the percentage of the variation of the trait within the group of dogs you are looking at. So most behavior traits are moldy heritable which means you can breed for that trait but environment also plays a factor. Go to the institute of canine biology they are also a member here which I never knew but any ways there is a lot of great stuff about breeding there. Anyways a cur whose parents were both deep game and grand parents were also deep game and had a decent percentage of deep game siblings and aunts and uncles had an incredibly good chance of throwing game offspring. The reason you look at all the relatives I mentioned is for the EBV which can be calculated if we had the data we would need. It stands for estimated breeding values. They are widely used by livestock breeders. Anyways since we don’t have the numbers to crunch you look at the family as a whole like stated above. This works for any behavior trait or physical trait like conformation. Is it always going to work no but it will more times than not. This is why I would breed to a cut like I mentioned above over a grch with cur parents grandparents and siblings. Believe me this stuff works and a lot of the old timers instinctively knew this stuff just didn’t know the science behind it. These great breeders were well ahead of there time and were extremely intelligent and didn’t even know how much of what they knew was actually provable
     
  4. slim12

    slim12 CH Dog Staff Member

    Great post.

    I am not a breeder by any stretch of the imagination.

    I do believe that it is the average of the family that is important. A litter of five with 3 curs, a plug and an all out freak. When the freak that wins five or six is bred the odds of getting his brothers and sisters are pretty good.

    On the flip side if there a a bunch of relatives that are game with skills then odds are that is what you get as well.

    And of course, there are exceptions. Sometimes a pedigree is chock full of game and winning dogs and a dog throws nothing but curs, regardless of his mate.

    The hard part to prove in the equation is that when a dog curs he seldom gets the chance to proof the rest of his family.

    My buddy had a litter out of Patrick's Kasai to a Medlins Outlaw female called Schnatterly's Rabbit Foot. 7 dogs in the litter. We managed to buy them all back except for one female. The six we got back all made it to the show. The one female was deemed a brood dog from day one never really got a shot. I would have no problem doing a breeding with her and having something off of her.

    Patrick's Kasai was bred to Fat Bill's Miss Two Eyes. I had two out of the litter. Both made it to the show. The female won one and lost one. The male collected a forfeit and went on to do big things in a camp that rode up and down the road with a lot of $$$ riding on each trip. He faired well.

    His brother went to a pet home. I'd breed to him too.

    We came home with a deep game losing bitch once and the winner was sold for a shit load of money pit side. I was asked what I thought and I said she was a cur looking for a place to quit. She was a tremendous biter and we did not have enough dog to find the cur I thought was there. She came back out for a boat load of cash and hung it up real early. Her brother did one in and walked away on top. She had another brother that won 4 times. I say he was a game dog. Knowing/seeing his brother and sister I would be hard pressed to breed to him. I can see where some people would breed to a winning/game dog and I can't find fault in that decision. If I just knew the winning/game dog I might take my chances. Seeing the family hang it up would be reason for pause.

    Never heard the Sapelo story, only heard she quit.

    I missed out on owning a male/female pair out of Huckleberry to his daughter Hannah. I was a little slow pulling the trigger and missed out. I never knew of a disconnect with Arrangadanga.

    Sorry for the length. Babbling.

    S
     
  5. Fl0w

    Fl0w Pup

    Thank you very much for the insight, I'm gonna take a look at this institute of canine biologily, had already heard about them before but never had any feedback. Genetic is quite awesome and fascinating!

    Please never stop babbling. Almost each time you post here I learn something and I'm pretty convinced that I'm not the only one.
    Thanks for that Sir=D>
     
    Blackpolarbear and ngamla like this.
  6. stickler

    stickler Big Dog

    I do not believe it is a gene, or better said, I do not believe it is a single gene.
    I believe it must just be the right combination of the right genes.
     
    Dusty Road, PlugUgly and c_note like this.
  7. stickler

    stickler Big Dog

    Well, sure ...
    But it means you would breed to the freak in that family of game dogs, so to say.
    Do you still like the idea ? :P:D
     
  8. slim12

    slim12 CH Dog Staff Member

    Freaks seldom throw more freaks. It happens but it is not the norm. I think you have to look at the family as a whole and then use words like typical and atypical.

    If the family is chock full of game dogs with winning traits then getting the same from breeding them would be typical. And if one of those dogs out of that litter is a 'freak' that is atypical, then breeding to him will more than likely give him something more like the average of his relatives which could be looked at a freak not throwing more freaks.

    The opposite is probably more true. When the family is chock full of curs, rank or walk away types, and then that freak winning dog pops up when he is bred he throws what his family is made of....freaks seldom throw more freaks. He will more than likely throw typical to what he is made of, not his atypical freakdom.

    And then the conversation starts to define the term freak as it applies to dogs. Very few are referring to gameness when using the term freak. Most of the time it is mouth and ability. Mouth, ability and great conditioning can hide the cur. Nothing ever lasted long enough with Molly Bee to even hint at her being a game dog but she would be my pick as the greatest match dog of all time. She was a freak and although in a small number of breedings nothing never measured up to what she laid out in 8 different trips.

    For me, the entire little get together in these dogs is winning. I never annointed myself nor expected anyone else to perpetuate the breed. I was really glad some people did so, but I just never remember anyone saying I am leaving home on a late Saturday night with all the money I can muster because I have a really, really deep game dog.

    People discard all the basic principles and breed to freaks in hopes of getting the next freak. And I have seen a few that would want to make me go that route too. LOL

    I wish as a younger kid I would have put some thoughts and efforts into breeding dogs. What little knowledge I have, and I stress little, came as I got older and things started to slow down. I look back and there were tons of dogs that should have been bred because they were game, they had winnable traits and most importantly they had those same type family members.

    Great topic. I really enjoy reading about breeding dogs. I wish I had more real life experience in choosing partners and looking back I see there were a ton of dogs I should have bred and a few that I should have not.

    S
     
  9. Soze the killer

    Soze the killer Top Dog

    great way of saying things...very deep explanation...
    I'm not gonna ramble on ,coz I'm no one to do so...
    But I've always thought about these freaks:when God breaks the mold.the mold gets truely broken,and can never be made again..and it needs to be considered,that if the animal is that much of a freak..then even if it's offspring are good.well there still gonna be a shade disappointing compared to the said freak what produced them..

    How many bloodlines or family's produce freaks with regulatory?,how many bloodlines produce GAME freaks with regulatory?...
    Probably not many?..

    the way you say "typical" ..and "atypical "......is,I have to say a genius way of explaining "freaks"...I've never thought of it like that.but it makes a lot of sense.
     
    stickler likes this.
  10. stickler

    stickler Big Dog

    I'm probably the first one ever using the term Freak on a game family bred dog, lol, but it was meant more of a joke, of course.

    Typical and atypical are much better terms, when talking about family bred dogs.

    A freak is a freak.
    And an ace is an ace, typical or atypical does not matter at all in such a case.
    What kind of dogs are able to beat an ace ? Probably only another ace or a freak-dog.
    So atypical from a family of curs and from a family of game dogs is of course a huge difference.
    A freak most probably is the 'one in a million' dog, that comes from these so called scatter breedings.
    Guess, we do know all kind of freaks in these dogs, but if they are not unbeatable then ... :D

    The atypical dog from a game family might be a good choice for a breeder who breeds back to his own dogs, perhaps using the dog as somewhat as an outcross into his oIwn family. Might be worth a try before using a 'real' outcross.

    slim12, all of your writings are a pleasure to read and to think about. Thank you.

    "WHEN A MAN GETS TOO OLD TO SET A BAD EXAMPLE HE BEGINS HIS POTENTIAL TO OFFER GOOD ADVISE.
    I HOPE I HAVE SOME TIME LEFT THAT I MIGHT REACH THIS AREA. AT LEAST THE FORMER." B.K.
     
    corvettedex and Soze the killer like this.
  11. oldguy

    oldguy Top Dog

    corvettedex and Soze the killer like this.
  12. oldguy

    oldguy Top Dog

    Junkyard Boys Grand Champion Bill
    Junkyard Boy`s Gr.Ch.Bill (2).jpg
     
  13. AGK

    AGK Super duper pooper scooper Staff Member

    corvettedex and Soze the killer like this.
  14. Soze the killer

    Soze the killer Top Dog

    Perhaps not unbeatable?.but if two real freaks meet,they probably not gonna be here after it...and it's gonna be one of the greatest battles
    How many of today's dogs would last even five minutes with him?.a true legend of a Bulldog!
     
  15. corvettedex

    corvettedex CH Dog Premium Member

    Good thread, Im certainly not a breeder, I believe that a Freak is so devastating beyond anything many have seen in a lifetime. I also believe in the words of the Howard Hienzl, " In all his years he only saw 3 Dead game bulldogs. None of the 3 ever made so much as a turn, in there life or before they left it. To have a dead game dog that still alive is nothing more than wishful thinking"! I realize that was written long ago and with today's science and medicine recovery etc there's probably been a few that's been brought back to life. Did successful dogman bred curs. Of course they did. Yep that's where the gift comes in , also placement in very capable hands of their offspring, ect. But I'll go to my grave with this statement. If we lose the integrity of breeding for gameness first , we will lose integrity of bulldog. Jmo
     
    Blackpolarbear and Southbanker like this.
  16. slim12

    slim12 CH Dog Staff Member

    I would venture a guess that there are a bunch that would last. I believe there is always one out there. Every couple of years the next great thing comes along. Then it is hard to compare eras and history.

    I have seen a couple, maybe three all out freaks. Out of the three I thought only one would have proved game. The other two I thought would hang it up the first time things did not go there way, but they had so much mouth it would be hard for anything to take them to that 'no fly' zone.

    I have never seen a dead game dog, what I have seen is a dead dog and a dumb ass standing there really proud of his own stupidity, and the kicker being him being too stupid to even realize how stupid. If that makes sense. It is not like it is a gunshot kill in an instant, there is always time to pick one up, always.

    I think most pedigrees have curs. Not because I am thinking that deeply but because when dogs are tested more quit than stay. So the dogs usually fall into one of three categories, untested, checked and have someone's subjective opinion of being game and then curs. The number of untested and cur dogs are maybe 6:1. Maybe a little less and I am sort of hard on my bulldog brethren or maybe I am going light and it is maybe 10:1. Just way more curs and untested dogs so basic math says they are well represented in the dogs.

    I think what clouds my thought process the most is that the few dogs I have bred I never factored in gameness in the equation. I always bred dogs that won. My approach was always that gameness had to be understood, it was a given. I was taught that removing curs from the gene pool had nothing to do with culling. Culling was used on game dogs that could not win. Looking back, a real dumb way to go about things. But the guy that showed me the dogs only cared about winning and nothing about breeding. I learned that way and just assumed that was the way everyone else thought as well. Luckily there were breeders who had a better understanding of the big picture than me. I grew up thinking if he was two years old and still around, he had won, was able to win again or on his way to his first shot. Other than that they simply did not get to hold down a chain space. Again, a brain dead way to go about things but it takes all kinds to make things go around.

    So I think the greatest dogs of all time, freaks and aces and incredibly deep game dogs have the cur factored in somewhere. On the subject I guess I am the half glass empty thinker, and I liberally use the word 'thinker'.

    Again, great subject. Great thread.

    S
     
  17. oldguy

    oldguy Top Dog

    100% true! Bang on the money! Bogus Earl Tudors, idiots and ego driven cruel bastards squeezing one more run out a game dog that was probably beat before it got to the venue, wheels fell off after 15mins and needed picked up an hour ago.. Plenty game dogs have lost, just as many that were less game have won, some dogs know they're beat and just keep on going anyway, but one of the gamest I remember was a 38lb male, went over an hour pushing 4lb uphill in the hands of an imbecile.. The dog was light years behind and still the crazy fucker thought he was winning! He went on to become champion in other hands.
     
  18. corvettedex

    corvettedex CH Dog Premium Member

    I too have seen with my own eyes many years ago, a bulldog going uphill almost 20 pounds on his back for 45 minutes taken a hellacious beating, but refused to quit, he actually cured out the bigger harder biting bulldog at the hour mark. Both of them had run hot, and the bigger bulldog would not come back across. The bulldog that was on his back taking such a beating with a broken front leg, craweled and flipped and pushed back across to get back to the bulldog that was killing him. It was a Hot summer day in July, he was so exhausted he couldn't even stand up as his paws were flipping underneath him, and for the few folks that saw it , had tears in their eyes. As he pushed, flipped , crawled and screamed to complete the deepest game scratch I've ever seen. In person. He was as close to being a dead game bulldog. He was picked up and saved. He was a pure Colby dog.( Rip) to a rattle snake bite summer of 2017..
     
    reids skipper likes this.
  19. Soze the killer

    Soze the killer Top Dog

    Awesome thread this folks...keep the great info coming,.....

    And no one wants to be going home with one in a bag.it can happen.but should not happen really..as Slim says: "a dumb ass standing there really proud of his own stupidity"........and Oldguy:" idiots and ego driven cruel bastards squeezing one more run out of a game dog that was probably beat before it got to the venue"........And Dex,it sounds like you you were trying to see if your game dog would quit?.sounds like a hellish beating,.and ide of had tears in my eyes to......must of been the last of the real Colby dogs,that's for sure.
     
    david63 and corvettedex like this.
  20. slim12

    slim12 CH Dog Staff Member

    I like the sayings and cliches in the dogs, and I like when they are attributed to certain people, big names in the dogs. One of my favorites is that they will all quit at some point, or in so many words, from the Mountain Man. Another was told to me by the guy that turned me onto the dogs so many years ago, be surprised when they make it, not when they quit and he followed that up and said you have to love your dogs, but you can't be in love with your dogs.

    Back to the post, if they will all quit then they all are from curs.

    The problem with a lot of people they go in search of the curs thru shitty breeding, shitty raising, shitty care and then unnecessarily beating the shit out of them, or expecting them to turn on and turn off like a light switch.

    The opposite should be the path. We should do everything we can to hide the cur deep down and thru selection in breeding and proper schooling and great conditioning the cur stays hidden.

    I see the dog life as a triangle. The bottom is a very wide base. On each bottom corner are two dogs being selected for breeding. From that point anything and everything in that dogs life shapes him and whittles him down until the very tip at the top, the sharpest point of the top tip of that triangle. And when he is at that razor sharp tip there will be a man in the corner saying, "release your dog". From that point on for the next 30-60-90 minutes is where a person will see how to change the way he whittles down the sides of that triangle. It may go all the way to the bottom a change the selection process or it may be schooling or feed or care or conditioning. It may be all of them combined. Only, and I repeat, only that 30-60-90 minute window will define the course.

    I know people who have raised the same family of dogs for a ton of years and they know the dogs they have. Sometimes Dog C gets a pass because dogs A & B did the exact same thing along with dogs D-Z. So he may skip a step here and there and still get to the top of that triangle. That experience can't be replaced nor substituted.

    The problem arises is when I get a dog from so and so and I do not have the 6-8 generations of experience and I give that same pass because of the pedigree and the names on the pedigree. I quickly start walking down that slippery slope......

    S
     

Share This Page